Corporate Services, Inc.
208 Kishwaukee St. · Rockford, IL 61104
(p) (815) 962-8367 · (f) (815) 962-0940

Age Bias Suit: Little White Lies About Worker's Departure Come Back to Haunt Employer


Sometimes employers feel the need to finesse the reason why an employee is leaving the company — to avoid damaging morale.

While the intentions may be good, a new lawsuit serves as a great example of why not to do that.

Hired at 63, fired at 64

When Wesley Enhanced Living, a retirement community, fired CFO DeWayne McMullin, he filed an age discrimination lawsuit against Wesley (case). McMullin, who was 64, was replaced by a 52-year-old.

Wesley said McMullin was fired because he continually made errors in financial reports and cash sheets.

The employer also believed it had strong grounds to get the lawsuit thrown out — namely McMullin was 63 when he was hired (he had only been on the job for a year). Surely, the fact that they hired him at 63 proves Wesley was not guilty of age bias, right?

Not so fast. The court ruled a jury should hear McMullin's case because:

  • Wesley told its employees McMullin resigned — not that he was fired, and
  • the CEO said two staffers complained to him about McMullin's performance, but they testified that while they had concerns, they never discussed them with the CEO.

So the court said, "Based on the record [...] a jury could find Wesley's explanation for terminating McMullin incredible. Such a finding may give rise to an inference of discrimination."

Now Wesley is facing an expensive legal battle or settlement.

Posted In: Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA); Discrimination, Illegal

Want to know more? Read the full article by Christian Schappel at HR Morning

More News from Corporate Services, Inc.

Letter 226J? IRS's New ACA Enforcement Comes at a Terrible Time

Human resources professionals can be forgiven if they are a bit skeptical about the warnings from the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) to collect employer mandate penalties under the Affordable Care Act (ACA), largely due to the agency's apparent lack of follow-through. However, with the latest warning, the agency now includes some proof that this time it is for real.more

Tricky Human Resources Situations

With the multitude of issues human resources professionals face, it can be difficult to know under which circumstances legal assistance is necessary. Because, when it comes down to it, there is no instruction manual.more