Corporate Services, Inc.
208 Kishwaukee St. · Rockford, IL 61104
(p) (815) 962-8367 · (f) (815) 962-0940

Employee Fakes Cancer to Get Leave: How Vigilant Manager Stopped the Abuse


When an employee requests time off because of something as serious as a cancer diagnosis, most of the time the person will be telling the truth about her situation. But as a recent case shows, if a manager has even an inkling that something is amiss, it pays to take a closer look.

In the case of former U.S. Postal Service (USPS) employee Caroline Boyle, a supervisor's skepticism likely foiled an egregious — and illegal — abuse of leave.

Here is what happened: Boyle let her supervisor know she needed to take some time off because she had been diagnosed with non-Hodgkins lymphoma. The request came after the 25-year veteran was denied a promotion. Over the 20 months that followed the request, Boyle took 112 days of sick leave and worked part-time to attend her frequent doctor's visits.

Boyle's manager even allowed her to work from home and approved paid administrative leave that did not count against her sick leave.

Incorrect spelling sparks questions

Boyle provided a number of doctor's notes to support her time-off and other accommodation requests for her cancer. However, more than a year after letting USPS know about her "condition," a manager became suspicious about her claims.

That suspicion prompted a USPS investigator to take a closer look at the doctor's notes that had been provided. During that process, the investigator discovered that Boyle had spelled one of her cancer doctor's names incorrectly. This led the investigator to question all of the facilities in which Boyle claimed to receive treatment and, lo and behold, none of those facilities had any record of Boyle as a patient.

Losing her job at the USPS was the least of Boyle's concerns. She was also indicted by a federal grand jury on felony counts of forged writings, wire fraud and possession of false papers to defraud the United States.

Based on a former subordinate's situation

The real drama in this case actually took place in the courtroom, where Boyle admitted not only to faking her cancer diagnosis but also revealed her motive for doing so — i.e. she was upset because she did not get a promotion.

Stranger still, Boyle essentially based her entire fraudulent leave claim on a former subordinate of hers. During the sentencing, Lisa Roberts testified that Boyle's made-up cancer diagnosis was a carbon copy of her real one.

Furthermore, when Roberts requested time off for treatment, Boyle accused her of faking the cancer diagnosis to take a long vacation, prodded Roberts on the reason she did not lose her hair and demanded that Roberts turn over her confidential medical records.

Roberts said Boyle used those very same medical records to back up her own fake cancer diagnosis.

While the details of this strange, strange case sound like something plucked straight from a made-for-TV movie, the takeaway for employers is easily transferrable to more pedestrian workplace situations: if a manager suspects something is amiss with an employee's leave request, allow the manager to follow her instincts — provided she does so within the specific confines of the relevant applicable laws. After all, front-line managers are often your first-line of defense against leave abuse.

Posted In: Fraud, Abuse, and Scams; Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA)

Want to know more? Read the full article by Jared Bilski at HR Morning

More News from Corporate Services, Inc.

Return of the ACA Individual Mandate: Could This Incarnation Catch On?

When the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) killed the penalty on the Affordable Care Act's (ACA) individual mandate, most employers believed the ACA was effectively dead. But some states did not think killing the mandate was such a great idea and put forward legislation to keep the mandate alive on the state level.more